A rebrand or brand refresh marks a new chapter in your organization’s story. The agency you choose will help write it. Get it right and you’ll have a brand that moves your business forward for years. Get it wrong, and you’ll be doing it again in three years.

For most marketing leaders, the real question isn’t “who does nice work?” It’s “who can actually think with us, challenge us when we need it, and turn our story into a something that lands with the right people?” This guide is designed to help you find that partner.

Start with your story

A strong branding agency starts with your story. Before you discuss color palettes, the agency should dig into:

• Your mission, vision, and values
• Your audiences and what they really care about
• Your proof points, such as results, testimonials, or impact
• The competitive landscape you operate in

If an agency jumps to moodboards before they’ve defined positioning, differentiation, and goals, that’s a problem. Your brand identity should be the expression of a strategy, not a decoration on top of one.

Helpful questions to ask

• How do you typically start a branding engagement?
• What do you need from us before you begin creative work?
  ‍

Look for strategic depth, not just deliverables

Good branding clarifies who you are, who you serve, and why you’re different. It gives your team a shared language. Strong agencies build that foundation through research and discovery, including stakeholder interviews, market insights and competitive positioning.

A branding agency should deliver:

• A positioning framework and messaging hierarchy
• Clear guidance on how your brand should show up across channels
  

TIP: In conversations and pitch meetings, notice how much time an agency spends on strategy. Do they talk about brand architecture, naming, and messaging hierarchy, or only about visuals and “vibes”?

Helpful questions to ask

• How do you approach research and discovery for a new brand or rebrand?
• Can you share an example of how strategy shaped the creative direction for a client like us?
  ‍
  

Evaluate brand agency creative chemistry (the right way)

It is easy to fall in love with a beautiful portfolio. The trick is to look one layer deeper. When you’re reviewing an agency’s work, focus on three things:

• ‍Range: Do you see different solutions for different clients, or does everything look the same?
• ‍Relevance: Have they worked with organizations of a similar size, complexity, or industry?
• ‍Problem‑solving: Can they explain what problem the work was solving and what it achieved?
  

You want an agency that can adapt to your category without copying your competitors. The goal is a brand that feels authentic to you and distinct from your competitors instead of a template with your logo dropped in.

Helpful questions to ask

• Which project in your portfolio feels closest to what we need, and why?
• How did you measure success for that engagement?
  ‍

Ask who will actually work on your brand

Many agencies impress in the pitch, winning business with their A-team, then hand the work to a rotating cast of juniors. For a high‑stakes brand project, continuity matters. You want a stable, senior team that understands your business and stays with you from kickoff through launch.

When you meet with prospective partners, make sure to find out:

• Who will lead strategy and who will lead creative?
• Who will be your day‑to‑day contact, and how senior are they?
• How long has the core team worked together?

Agencies with low turnover, experienced staff, and long client relationships signal that you are more likely to get a true partnership instead of a revolving door of talent.
‍

Understand their process and what working together will feel like

A healthy branding process should be structured and collaborative. A well-run branding engagement has defined phases with opportunities to weigh in along the way. Look for:

• ‍Defined phases, such as discovery, strategy, creative development, refinement, and rollout.
• ‍Milestones and feedback loops, so you know when and how to weigh in.
• ‍Decision frameworks, so rounds of feedback move the work forward instead of in circles.
  

You should feel included, but not asked to play creative director. The right agency will welcome your input at the right moments, explain tradeoffs clearly, and keep the project on track to make sure your brand goals are reached.

Helpful questions to ask

• Can you walk us through a typical branding timeline from kickoff to launch?
• How do you handle conflicting feedback from different stakeholders?
  ‍
  

Check for cultural fit and shared values

The best branding agency for you is both capable and compatible. As you talk with potential partners, pay attention to:

• ‍How they communicate: are they direct and clear, or do they lean on jargon?
• ‍Their creative range: will they give you options that are conservative, bold, and comfortably in between?
• ‍How they talk about results: logos and layouts, or business outcomes and behavior change?

If you want a brand that elevates your position in the market, you need an agency that’s comfortable challenging assumptions and bringing new ideas, while still respecting your needs.

Helpful questions to ask

• Tell us about a time you challenged a client’s thinking in a productive way?
• How do you balance staying on brand with trying something new?
  ‍
  

A 10‑question checklist for your next agency conversation

Use this quick checklist as you evaluate branding partners. A strong agency should give you confident, specific answers to each.

1. How do you define success for a branding project?
2. What do you need to learn about our business before you start creative work?
3. How do you approach research and audience insights?
4. What does your strategy deliverable usually include?
5. Can you walk us through a past project that felt like a true creative breakthrough — and what made it work?
6. Who will be on our core team and how long have they worked together?
7. What does your process look like from kickoff to launch?
8. How do you handle feedback and keep projects on schedule?
9. How will you help our team use the new brand after launch?
10. What makes you a better fit for us than your competitors?

If you need a branding partner who leads with strategy and collaborates with your through launch, we’d love to help you write your next chapter with clarity and confidence.

‍